I have always suspected that my first born is what can be termed ‘a strong willed child.’ But because of his equally strong communication skills, in the past we have been able to side step all out temper tantrums by talking him through his fears and frustrations. However, over the last month or so we have encountered an issue with Corbin that we cannot simply reason away. He has started screaming every time we put him in his bed and waking up in hysterics several times throughout the night. We have tried to take a firm stance on this, but it has proven difficult to tackle disciplinary situations at bed time because by that point in the day we are so exhausted that our resolve is weakened. I don’t know why, but bed time has just always been a sore spot with Corbin. We have marveled as month after month we can lay a wide awake Bennett down in his bed and he simply rolls over and goes to sleep…for the entire night! We have never gotten more than a few weeks at a time of such blissful sleeping patterns out of Corbin. This is not to say that we compare one child’s behavior to another, it is just to say that we have been surprised to find that perhaps our first-born’s erratic sleep patterns are not necessarily the norm.
I know part of the problem is that we have tried too many tactics in addressing this issue recently and have ultimately undermined our strength in his young eyes. We have tried rationalizing with him about his fears of giants in his closet or bad dreams that creep under his door to get him. But I think that in giving them so much attention in our conversations we may have inadvertently validated these irrational fears. We have also tried coaxing him into making a better choice by offering positive reinforcement. We told him that if he could go a certain number of days without crying in his bed he would be rewarded with a special trip to the Chattanooga Aquarium. This idea sounded just fine to him during the day light hours, but as soon as darkness fell he announced that he did not want to go to the Aquarium because he was scared that the fish would try to bite him. He then proceeded to scream in his room for over an hour. The next night we tried a more immediate and known reward by offering to let him watch a movie of his choice the following morning if he could go just one night without screaming. He told us that he didn’t want to watch a movie because it might give him a bad dream and kept right on screaming. Since positive reinforcement hadn’t worked, several nights later we moved onto the negative. Corbin was told that he would not be allowed to watch his beloved Mickey Mouse Club House or Clifford the Big Red Dog if he chose to scream in his bed that night. As of today he has not been allowed to watch any television in a week…and the screaming continues. We have even resorted to spankings, a form of punishment that is reserved for only the most extreme disciplinary cases in our home, but it has done absolutely nothing to diffuse his fits. In fact we are starting to suspect that just by going into his room to administer the punishment we are giving him exactly what he wants – more attention. Corbin’s nightly tantrum escalated to Super Nanny proportions last night. After screaming hysterically while jumping up and down on his bed for about twenty minutes, we heard him get out of bed and begin opening and closing drawers in his dresser. Several minutes later we were standing together outside of his bedroom when the inevitable happened. His door cracked open and a tearful Corbin slowly emerged making whiny pleas to sleep in our bed or come play in the bonus room with us. The one humorous moment in this frustrating ordeal came when we asked him why he had been opening and closing his dresser drawers. “I tried to hide in my jammies drawer,” he replied ruefully, “but my head wouldn’t fit.” Sadly our laughter was short lived because what ensued was an hour and a half battle of wills that ultimately ended in me replacing the child lock on his door knob and him screaming and making empty threats as he dismantled his entire closet. He eventually screamed himself to sleep at which point Chris and I retreated to bed feeling utterly defeated.
I am well aware of the mistakes that we have made in dealing with this issue. And I am also aware that the main cause for my lack of resolve is that what I see manifesting in my son right now is an amalgamation of several of what I consider to be my deepest character flaws. It is so hard to see my son exhibiting signs of having inherited my irrational fears, my controlling nature and my general tendency to indulge my darker emotions. That being said, I believe that I am in the process of surrendering all of this: the mistakes I have made in parenting, the sins that I have passed on and modeled for my children, and the sins that are all their own, to my heavenly father. God knows my issues and he knows Corbin’s, and he desires for both of us to walk in the freedom that he already bought for us. I do not know the perfect way to tackle this issue. And I confess there are times that it seems larger than life. My inability to handle Corbin’s sleeping problems perfectly could very easily define the way that I view myself as a mother right now. But that will not do any of us one bit of good. So instead I am asking for God’s peace in the midst of conflict. I of all people should know that you cannot simply reason or discipline away another person’s irrational fears. Parenting books and tips definitely have their place, but I think that first we need to ask God to deal with the deeper issues of the heart. I honestly don’t have a plan for dealing with the screaming tonight, other than to commit this evening to prayer throughout the day, and to ask God to give me the ability to forgive myself and give me fresh eyes for my son. This parenting thing, like everything else in life, is a process. Sometimes we will get it right and often we will fail miserably. But I believe that God has us here, walking through the process, for a reason. So today I am going to try to rest in that.